Prefetial logo PrefetialGetting things done, without the hustle noise
Organization

How to Keep a Someday List That Does Not Just Rot

Somewhere on your phone there is a note called Someday, or Ideas, or Maybe Later. Mine had 214 items in it when I finally sat down and counted. I had not opened it in seven months.

A laptop open to a plain text file of dated one line ideas beside a notebook where several lines have been crossed out

Somewhere on your phone there is a note called Someday, or Ideas, or Maybe Later. Mine had 214 items in it when I finally sat down and counted. I had not opened it in seven months. When I did open it, roughly a third of the entries were unreadable: "the garage thing", "ask R about the course", "that pricing idea". Three items were already done and two referred to a job I had left.

The usual conclusion is that the list was a waste of time and the fix is a better app. I think both halves of that are wrong. The list did its job the moment each line went into it, and the reason it rotted is that I wrote entries for the person who typed them rather than for the stranger who would read them half a year later. Those are two different people, and only one of them is still in the room.

What the list is actually for

A someday list lets you say no to something right now without losing it. That is the whole function. It is not a pipeline, not a backlog and not a plan.

There is decent research behind why that helps. Unfinished intentions keep surfacing, which is the effect Bluma Zeigarnik described in the 1920s and which gets invoked a lot more loosely than she meant it. The more useful finding came from Masicampo and Baumeister in 2011: when people made a specific plan for an unfinished goal, the goal stopped interfering with an unrelated task. Writing down the goal alone did less. Writing down a plan for it did most of the work.

That detail changes how the list should look. A line that says "Spanish" is a recorded worry. A line that says "hold a ten minute conversation in Spanish on a work call, after the spring project ships, two evenings a week" is a parked plan. The second one stops nagging you. The first one keeps nagging and also stops making sense by March.

The three ways it rots

Mine failed in exactly three ways, and every list I have looked at since fails in the same three.

  • Nouns instead of outcomes. "Newsletter". "Pension". "Loft". You knew what you meant. Six months later the word is a prompt for nothing.
  • Mixed grain. "Learn to sail" sits one line above "buy a new bike light". One is a year of weekends, the other is eleven minutes and nine pounds. Reading them in sequence makes the whole list feel heavy, so you stop reading it.
  • No expiry and no cost. Nothing ever leaves. A list that only grows is a list you learn to avoid, and avoidance generalises fast. Mine took the weekly review down with it.

The mixed grain problem is the sneakiest, because it looks like tidiness. Everything in one place feels organised. In practice a single list of 214 items where the entries differ in size by a factor of two hundred is not one list, it is four lists that have been stapled together.

Writing entries that survive six months

  1. Lead with the outcome, not the topic. Something you could tell a friend was finished. Not "pension", but "move the old workplace pension into the current one".
  2. Write the condition that would start it. "After the spring release", "when the car loan ends", "if I ever have a free Saturday in summer". This is the part that makes it a parked plan rather than an open loop.
  3. Date the line. Just the month. It costs four characters and it is the single most useful field, because an idea you wrote eighteen months ago and never once thought about since is answering its own question.
  4. Put a cost on it in one unit. Hours per week, or money, or both. Two evenings a week. Around 300 pounds. You are not estimating a project, you are recording what it felt like when you wanted it.
  5. Sort it into one of three buckets. Conditional, aspirational, or small and cheap. More on those below.
  6. Stop at about five lines. If an entry needs a paragraph, it is not a someday item. It is a project you have decided not to start, which belongs somewhere else with a date on it.

Writing an entry this way takes maybe forty seconds instead of four. That is the entire cost of the method, and it is the difference between a list you can skim and an archaeology site.

Three buckets, because they get different treatment

Conditional items are waiting on a specific event or date. Renew the passport in the spring of the year it expires. Ask about the training budget after the new manager settles in. These do not belong on a someday list at all. They belong on a calendar on the date the condition arrives, and moving them out is usually the fastest way to shrink the list by a quarter.

Aspirational items are the ones you want to want. Sailing. Learning to cook properly. Reading more. There is no pull yet, only a liking for the idea of yourself doing it. Keep them, review them rarely, and do not feel bad that they sit still for years. This is the bucket the list exists for.

Small and cheap items are anything under about thirty minutes and under whatever your trivial spend threshold is. The bike light. The dripping tap washer. These should never have gone to someday. They go on this week's list, and if they come back to someday twice, that is information about how little you care, which is also fine. The mechanics of catching those before they drift are in a simple system for not dropping the ball.

Why weekly review kills the list

The standard advice, straight out of the GTD tradition, is to review your someday list every week as part of the weekly review. I have come to think this is the main reason people abandon both the list and the review.

Consider what you are asking of yourself. Sit down on a Friday afternoon, already tired, and make a yes or no decision about 200 items you have mostly already decided no to. The outcome is predictable. You skim, you decide nothing, you feel a low grade guilt about the list, and the next week you skip that section. Within two months you skip the review entirely, which takes out the parts that were actually working.

I now review the someday list four times a year, in a twenty minute block, with a deletion quota. At least a fifth of the list has to go on each pass. Not deferred. Deleted. Three passes took mine from 214 items to 61, and nothing I deleted has come back to haunt me. The items I did end up starting were, in almost every case, ones I remembered without needing the list at all, which tells you something uncomfortable about how much of the list was ever going to move.

Deletion is the function here, not a maintenance chore. A list that cannot shrink stops being a record of what you might do and becomes a record of what you have failed to do, and those two documents feel completely different to open. Keeping the rest of the weekly habit light is covered in how to run a weekly review.

The quarterly pass, in practice

Set a timer for twenty minutes. For each item, one of four outcomes: start it now, put it on the calendar, delete it, or keep it with a fresh date. No fifth option, no thinking about it later.

The question I use for the keep or delete call is narrow on purpose: if next week were completely free, would I start this on Monday? Not would I enjoy it, not is it a good idea. Would I start it. A surprising number of beloved items fail that, and they are the ones clogging the list.

If deleting feels impossible, move the item to a separate archive file. One rule: you never read the archive. It exists so you can let go of something without the feeling of throwing it away, and in two years I have opened mine once, to settle an argument. That is a reasonable price for making the main list honest. A read later pile has the same problem for the same reason, handled in organising a read later list you actually read.

FAQ

Where should the list live?

One plain text file or one note, with no due dates attached. Putting someday items into a task manager as tasks means they generate overdue badges, and a system that shows you red numbers for things you deliberately chose not to do will teach you to ignore red numbers.

How many items is too many?

If you cannot read the whole list in ten minutes, it is too long to be useful. For most people that lands somewhere around sixty entries written the way described above.

What if deleting an idea feels like giving up?

Use the archive file. The emotional weight is in the act of removing, not in whether the text still exists somewhere. Giving yourself a place to put it costs nothing and raises the deletion rate a lot.

Is this the same thing as a read later list?

No. A read later list holds things to consume, usually in under an hour, and it needs frequent pruning because content goes stale. A someday list holds things to become, and it tolerates years of stillness.

NB
Nadia Belov

Nadia writes about habit change and productivity tools, translating behavior research into things people can actually do.

More posts by Nadia

More in Organization

01doorganico 084goad 3hot8 4465456 after5internprogram ahandfulofblessings ahmadpc ahomcybersecurity allodialresources annodex antiquesandperiodcollectibles aotc asianworldkashmir beedlectrics bloggertemplatefree bluefeatheragency bodyweightsolution campaign08blog carfixadvisor catstreetcollective cbstvsports cnfanspurchasing committeeof500yearsofdignityandresistance covertopsdjs cs-kaiyuangame cuestacomunicaciontotal cxoutlet dancebetgame deskgearhub destinyvillastay detectmagazine di33 diamondsteelbuildings donmo dyanadropship emarsysfinance emimattl escapechan eskitarih evautoplay everythingweddings-orlando farmzone feedviewerapp foxstudiosscratch gamevui123 gleasongrade greetingsday hacklabasu haskell iw-kaiyun jagoanproperti jilidskripsi joltbusinessfinance juegodepokergratis juegospucca kaeru-festival latestmehndidesigns lestanzediottaviano litemagazines localcommunityhero lustrsazan mariashebets menswheels newwebstechs1 nikkit ootheday oxigenvpn plurfitness probudgetcarpetcleaning psychicmrsmartin pyaten qvantor rejoignezlogis rexzbot riselayouts ruchin rwxqsgd5 sakaltime shibiaowang shop-bot skrtips spotlesshaven strcoding tetapatrium topselller uneplanteartificielle vipertechcr webtech1223411 wo-kygaming yamaha-mekar yeknava yoybuysheets zenunwa yamaha-mekar jilidskripsi ankertoto ankertoto ankertoto